Technology & the Internet

( use the left and right arrows to navigate, or scroll )

Laurel Schwulst / Lecture for Princeton VIS 208. Graphic Design: Link, Spring 2025

Part 1.
What is Technology?

Technology tends to become mythic. I use this word in the sense in which it was used by the French literary critic, Roland Barthes. He used the word "myth" to refer to a common tendency to think of our technological creations as if they were God-given, as if they were a part of the natural order of things. I have on occasion asked my students if they know when the alphabet was invented. The question astonishes them. It is as if I asked them when clouds and trees were invented. The alphabet, they believe, was not something that was invented. It just is. It is this way with many products of human culture but with none more consistently than technology. Cars, planes, TV, movies, newspapers--they have achieved mythic status because they are perceived as gifts of nature, not as artifacts produced in a specific political and historical context.
Technology tends to become mythic. I use this word in the sense in which it was used by the French literary critic, Roland Barthes. He used the word "myth" to refer to a common tendency to think of our technological creations as if they were God-given, as if they were a part of the natural order of things. I have on occasion asked my students if they know when the alphabet was invented. The question astonishes them. It is as if I asked them when clouds and trees were invented. The alphabet, they believe, was not something that was invented. It just is. It is this way with many products of human culture but with none more consistently than technology. Cars, planes, TV, movies, newspapers--they have achieved mythic status because they are perceived as gifts of nature, not as artifacts produced in a specific political and historical context.
Technology tends to become mythic. I use this word in the sense in which it was used by the French literary critic, Roland Barthes. He used the word "myth" to refer to a common tendency to think of our technological creations as if they were God-given, as if they were a part of the natural order of things. I have on occasion asked my students if they know when the alphabet was invented. The question astonishes them. It is as if I asked them when clouds and trees were invented. The alphabet, they believe, was not something that was invented. It just is. It is this way with many products of human culture but with none more consistently than technology. Cars, planes, TV, movies, newspapers--they have achieved mythic status because they are perceived as gifts of nature, not as artifacts produced in a specific political and historical context.
"Technology is incredible!" from versions of Pokémon ✶✶

the wheel
writing
books
electricity
jacquard
radio
flight
television
computers

Don’t read books!

Don’t chant poems!

When you read books
your eyeballs wither away leaving the bare sockets.

When you chant poems
your heart leaks out slowly with each word.

Excerpt of 12th century zen poem written by Chinese poet Yang Wanli and later translated by Jonathan Chaves ✶✶
It’s so much better

to close your eyes,
sit in your study,
lower the curtains,
sweep the floor,
burn incense.

It’s beautiful to listen to the wind,
listen to the rain,

take a walk when you feel energetic,
and when you’re tired go to sleep.
Excerpt of 12th century zen poem written by Chinese poet Yang Wanli and later translated by Jonathan Chaves ✶✶
Luddites, radical group of English textile workers from 19th century, who are known for smashing the latest looms, were less anti-technology and more pro-human
The original Luddites would answer that we are human. Getting past the myth and seeing their protest more clearly is a reminder that it’s possible to live well with technology—but only if we continually question the ways it shapes our lives. It’s about small things, like now and then cutting the cord, shutting down the smartphone and going out for a walk. But it needs to be about big things, too, like standing up against technologies that put money or convenience above other human values.
"What the Luddites Really Fought Against", Smithsonian, 2011 ✶✶

On the way from mythology to logistics, thought has lost the element of self-reflection, and today machinery disables men even as it nurtures them.

Dialectic of Enlightenment, by Adorno and Horkheimer, 1944
Ursula K. Le Guin, The Carrier Bag Theory of Fiction ✶✶

Technology is the active human interface with the material world.

Ursula K. Le Guin, 2005 ✶✶
What Shape is the Internet? By Noah Veltman ✶✶

Part 2.
A History of the Internet

( which includes the world wide web )

First submarine cables for the telegraph, 1830s-50s
Sputnik, 1957
DARPA, https://darpa.mil
While many have debated the origins of the Internet, it’s clear that in many ways it was built to withstand nuclear attack. The Net was designed as a solution to the vulnerability of the military’s centralized system of command and control during the late 1950’s and beyond. For, the argument goes, if there are no central command centers, then there can be no central targets and overall damage is reduced.
Alexander Galloway, Protocol
Panopticon (prison design) — Example of a centralized diagram
Flight Paths — Example of a decentralized diagram
US Highway System — Example of a distributed diagram
Packet Switching — continues idea that "many highly unreliable computers create a highly reliable network"
Early Physical Internet — Clip from Werner Herzog's "Lo and Behold" film, with Leonard Kleinrock
ARPANET, 1969
ARPANET, 1974
CYCLADES of France, Louis Pouzin
Earthrise
The “Whole Earth Catalog” was founded by Stewart Brand.

Brand teamed up with NASA to help release those first images of the earth from outer space.

He thought the image might be a powerful symbol, evoking a sense of shared destiny and adaptive strategies from people.
Whole Earth Catalog & Stewart Brand
Whole Earth Catalog & Stewart Brand
The catalog’s tagline was “access to tools” and focused on sharing DIY techniques and important knowledge any individual should know.
Whole Earth Catalog & Stewart Brand
An item is listed in the CATALOG if it is deemed:

- Useful as a tool,
- Relevant to independent education,
- High quality or low cost,
- Not already common knowledge,
- Easily available by mail.
Whole Earth Catalog & Stewart Brand
Whole Earth Catalog & Stewart Brand ✶✶
The cultural origin of the internet is related to 60s counter-culture. The rediscovering of liminal experience is the appeal. For people who don’t have some sort of spiritual practice, technological change is the thing that comes closest to the experience of the unreal. It’s similar to the experience of getting a cell phone call for the first time. “This is weird, this is magic.” There are are all kinds of spooky experiences. It’s not just newness, either—it’s an experience where the previous understanding of the universe is broken. You don’t get many experiences like that if you don’t do drugs or have some sort of meditative practice. You don’t play with social rules or create new social spaces. Magic changes the rules of the world in a way we don’t expect.
Eleanor Sattia
The cultural origin of the internet is related to 60s counter-culture. The rediscovering of liminal experience is the appeal. For people who don’t have some sort of spiritual practice, technological change is the thing that comes closest to the experience of the unreal. It’s similar to the experience of getting a cell phone call for the first time. “This is weird, this is magic.” There are are all kinds of spooky experiences. It’s not just newness, either—it’s an experience where the previous understanding of the universe is broken. You don’t get many experiences like that if you don’t do drugs or have some sort of meditative practice. You don’t play with social rules or create new social spaces. Magic changes the rules of the world in a way we don’t expect.
Eleanor Sattia
The cultural origin of the internet is related to 60s counter-culture. The rediscovering of liminal experience is the appeal. For people who don’t have some sort of spiritual practice, technological change is the thing that comes closest to the experience of the unreal. It’s similar to the experience of getting a cell phone call for the first time. “This is weird, this is magic.” There are are all kinds of spooky experiences. It’s not just newness, either—it’s an experience where the previous understanding of the universe is broken. You don’t get many experiences like that if you don’t do drugs or have some sort of meditative practice. You don’t play with social rules or create new social spaces. Magic changes the rules of the world in a way we don’t expect.
Eleanor Sattia
Internet architecture (hourglass model)
@
Email & Ray Tomlinson, 1971
What is the Internet, Anyway? From the TODAY show on NBC, 1994 ✶✶
IP
Internet Protocol, 1980
TCP
Transmission Control Protocol, 1980s
HTTP
Hypertext Transfer Protocol, 1990s
World Wide Web & Tim Berners Lee, 1989 (proposal)
WWW
World Wide Web & Tim Berners Lee, 1991
Professor Websites, Prof Dr. Style, via Olia Lialina, 1990s
Professor Websites, Prof Dr. Style, via Olia Lialina, 1990s
Professor Websites, Prof Dr. Style, via Olia Lialina, 1990s
Professor Websites, Prof Dr. Style, via Olia Lialina, 1990s
Professor Websites, Prof Dr. Style, via Olia Lialina, 1990s
Professor Websites, Prof Dr. Style, via Olia Lialina, 1990s
Ted Nelson's Watery Xanadu — Clip from Werner Herzog's "Lo and Behold" film, with Ted Nelson & Project Xanadu
Computer Lib / Dream Machines, Ted Nelson, 1974
Xanadu Space, Ted Nelson, 1990s
Xanadu Space, Ted Nelson, 1990s
The Internet Archive (logo) archive.org
The Internet Archive (building, SF) archive.org
On April 3rd, 1995, the first item was ordered from Amazon.com—John Wainwright ordered Douglas Hofstadter’s book Fluid Concepts and Creative Analogies.

A friend of his, the first Amazon employee, had invited him to a beta launch of Amazon.com. Wainwright thought the items would be free and was surprised when "they took my credit card and charged it!"

Amazon would later name a building after Wainwright on their corporate campus to commemorate the sale; he still has the packing slip.
First Amazon.com order, 1995 ✶✶
Wikipedia, 2001
Apple's iPhone, 2007
Anil Dash, The Web We Lost, 2013
It is worth remembering that the internet wasn't supposed to be like this. It wasn't supposed to be six boring men with too much money creating spaces that no one likes but everyone is forced to use because those men have driven every other form of online existence into the ground. The internet was supposed to have pockets, to have enchanting forests you could stumble into and dark ravines you knew better than to enter. The internet was supposed to be a place of opportunity, not just for profit but for surprise and connection and delight. Instead, like most everything American enterprise has promised held some new dream, it has turned out to be the same old thing—a dream for a few, and something much more confining for everyone else.
It is worth remembering that the internet wasn't supposed to be like this. It wasn't supposed to be six boring men with too much money creating spaces that no one likes but everyone is forced to use because those men have driven every other form of online existence into the ground. The internet was supposed to have pockets, to have enchanting forests you could stumble into and dark ravines you knew better than to enter. The internet was supposed to be a place of opportunity, not just for profit but for surprise and connection and delight. Instead, like most everything American enterprise has promised held some new dream, it has turned out to be the same old thing—a dream for a few, and something much more confining for everyone else.
It is worth remembering that the internet wasn't supposed to be like this. It wasn't supposed to be six boring men with too much money creating spaces that no one likes but everyone is forced to use because those men have driven every other form of online existence into the ground. The internet was supposed to have pockets, to have enchanting forests you could stumble into and dark ravines you knew better than to enter. The internet was supposed to be a place of opportunity, not just for profit but for surprise and connection and delight. Instead, like most everything American enterprise has promised held some new dream, it has turned out to be the same old thing—a dream for a few, and something much more confining for everyone else.
Diagram.website by Kristoffer Tjalve — a map of the optimistic web
Fish Screensaver by Linked by Air (with Laurel Schwulst), 2012
Internet Artifacts by Neal
Jisu Lee, websitesite.xyz
Special Fish by Elliott Cost
Claire L Evans, author of Broad Band: The Women Who Built the Internet ✶✶
Calm Technology, by Mark Weiser & John Seely Brown at Xerox PARC, 1996
The Internet of Things — Clip from Werner Herzog's "Lo and Behold" film, with Leonard Kleinrock
Networks of New York (book) by Ingrid Burrington

How do you *see* the internet?

We might first have to ask:

How does the internet *work*?

Networks of New York (book) by Ingrid Burrington
Networks of New York (book) by Ingrid Burrington
"Walking the Internet" Spring 2023 VIS 208 with Alex Wolfe
Class Website Spring 2023 — "Walking the Internet"
( end for now )